After the Pull

Why workers can spot a mistake and still stay silent, even with a button that stops production.

A worker leans back and pulls a blue rope that hangs from two hooks above a car body on an assembly line, while a supervisor in a suit points at her and shouts. The words the rope and yelled at sit above the scene.

The worker had a way to stop the line. He also had a reason not to use it.

John Shook described the scene in MIT Sloan Management Review. In early 1995, at an assembly plant outside Detroit, a worker made a mistake. He noticed it, but the car had already moved beyond his station.

There was no rope to pull and no team leader nearby. A red button sat about 30 paces away. Pressing it would stop the entire line and bring a supervisor.

The supervisor would come to help, though Shook thought the worker probably wouldn't like the "help" he got.

"So he did nothing."

At GM's old Fremont plant, Bruce Lee of the UAW recalled a rule workers knew well: "You saw a problem, you stop that line, you were fired."

You can give someone a button and still make silence the sensible choice. The worker outside Detroit had spotted the mistake while it was close enough to name.

The Fremont rule gave workers an answer before they raised a problem: stop the line and get fired.

The rope arrives

The andon cord offered a different way to handle that moment. As This American Life described it, a thin nylon rope hung from hooks along the assembly line.

The first pull called a team leader to the worker's station. It did not immediately stop production. The leader tried to fix the problem before the line reached a fixed stopping point.

If the problem remained, the line stopped there. The worker could ask for help without first shutting everything down.

GM installed cords in its own plants. A worker could reach for the rope, pull it, and bring the problem to someone's attention. But in some factories, This American Life reported, workers got yelled at for pulling.

A few plants cut the cords down.

At Van Nuys, some managers opposed stopping the line because their bonuses depended on how many cars rolled off it. A defect could move down the line while the car still counted toward the number that paid them.

A defect could move down the line while the car still counted.

A defect could move down the line while the car still counted. Dots, in order: the manager, the bonus, the defect, the count.

Click a numbered dot to see what it stands for. Start with 1.

What came after the pull

So why did the same rope work at NUMMI, the joint venture between GM and Toyota in Fremont?

Shook, who worked on Toyota's side at the launch, recalled GM colleagues questioning whether workers should have the right to stop the line. Toyota answered with "the obligation to stop it."

That obligation came with a promise. The team leader "will come to your aid within your job cycle," about a minute.

Someone had to come.

Earl Ferguson had worked for GM since 1964. In 1984, while training in Japan, he pulled an andon cord for the first time. Asked by This American Life whether he had been nervous, he said yes.

The line stopped for one bolt. They fixed it there.

"One bolt changed my attitude."

Help made the next pull worth making. That pull exposed another problem before more work depended on it. Fixing the problem where it began gave workers another reason to call for help.

The answer to one pull shaped the next.

GM's copied cords could feed the loop the other way. Yelling made another pull less worthwhile. Problems could travel onward while the car count still rewarded managers.

That adds to the lag: the distance between a mistake and the feedback needed to correct it, as the car moves beyond the worker's station. The person who knows first has learned to keep the knowledge there.

The person who knows first has learned to keep the knowledge there.

The person who knows first has learned to keep the knowledge there. Dots, in order: the worker, the knowledge, the car, the lag.

Click a numbered dot to see what it stands for. Start with 1.

Over 85% of NUMMI's workforce came from old GM Fremont. Shook reported absenteeism falling from routinely over 20% to a steady 2%. Quality went from GM's worst to its best in one year.

Those workers had changed what they did inside a changed system. Hanging a rope while workers still got yelled at for pulling it could let problems move beyond the station where a worker first saw the mistake.

Help has a cost

Perhaps staffing explains the difference better than permission does. Toyota could keep its promise because it paid for people to answer. On a 2012 plant visit in Toyota City, Mark Graban noted roughly one team leader for every eight workers.

That costs people and time. A kind word from someone with no time to help would not have fixed the bolt.

Permission has to be paid for.

But that cost is the permission: asking for help meant something because someone could give it. GM bought the cord without buying that answer.

The next worker

The next worker can see both the problem and what happened to the person who brought it. Asking people to speak up does little to erase what they have already watched happen.

What happens in your organization when someone surfaces a problem? Follow the answer past the invitation to speak, to the person who actually did.

The worker outside Detroit could have walked the 30 paces to the red button.

Permission is what comes after the pull.

I keep notes on how bad news is received.

Part of The Extra Chair, on how a new person adds more than their own work by giving everyone already there a possible conversation.