The Cheap Part

Why finished work can seem worth less when it takes less time, even when the result hasn't changed.

A man holds up a pocket watch beside the words two days, next to a small painting of hills on an easel. A tall stack of sketchbooks and framed canvases rises beside the easel, and a painter in glasses and a blazer stands with folded arms looking at it, next to the words a lifetime.

"The labour of two days is that for which you ask two hundred guineas," Attorney General Holker asked Whistler. Whistler replied that he asked it for "the knowledge of a lifetime."

The libel trial took place in London in November 1878. The year before, John Ruskin had attacked Whistler's Falling Rocket as "flinging a pot of paint in the public's face." Whistler sued.

Holker's question made the price sound absurd without requiring anyone to judge the painting. Put the days beside the guineas, and the arithmetic seemed enough.

The wording is from Whistler's own published account in 1890. No official court transcript survives.

But you can follow Holker's question without knowing anything about paint. Two days sounds like something you can check. Whether the picture deserves two hundred guineas asks more of you.

In August 2022, Jason Allen's Théâtre D'opéra Spatial won a blue ribbon and $300 at the Colorado State Fair. He had made it with Midjourney. It entered the Digital Arts/Digitally-Manipulated Photography category.

Allen told Kevin Roose at The New York Times: "I won, and I didn't break any rules."

One Twitter user wrote: "We're watching the death of artistry unfold right before our eyes."

If you've spent years learning a craft, you can recognize that impulse. Before you decide whether the result deserves its ribbon, you check what the maker did. Something made quickly seems to count for less.

Why should the hours change what you see?

What the hours told us

In 2004, Kruger, Wirtz, Van Boven and Altermatt gave 144 participants the same poem. Some were told it took four hours to write. Others heard eighteen.

The eighteen-hour poem received higher ratings and a higher estimated price. The words hadn't changed.

The eighteen-hour poem received higher ratings, though the words hadn't changed.

The eighteen-hour poem received higher ratings, though the words hadn't changed. Dots: the poem, the short hourglass, the tall hourglass, the same words.

Click a numbered dot to see what it stands for. Start with 1.

Another experiment used two paintings, said to take four or twenty-six hours. Changing the reported hours changed the ratings. Self-described art experts relied on the effort cue as much as novices.

A third experiment used a suit of armor, supposedly made in fifteen or 110 hours. Effort mattered more when the image was harder to see clearly.

What we call effort can be a guess about quality. When we can't judge the work itself, the hours give us something to use: more reported hours raised the price guess for a poem with the same words.

The findings need care. A 2023 replication paper found weaker effects for the paintings. Its first attempt with the poem found no effect; a second found partial support, but not for monetary value. The armor result remains unreplicated.

Those limits matter. Effort doesn't explain every judgment, and the evidence doesn't justify treating it as a universal rule.

Nor is the buyer's guess the same as the maker's attachment to what they finished. One concerns judging the work from outside. The other concerns loving it from inside.

What did you decide?

Allen brought a record of effort to the Copyright Office. He said he had entered prompts and revisions at least 624 times.

The Review Board still refused registration in September 2023. Allen would not exclude the AI-generated material from his application. The Board found that prompting did not make him the author of the Midjourney image. It left the status of his Photoshop edits open.

The Office's January 2025 report put its position plainly: "prompts alone do not provide sufficient human control." It also allowed that better tools could change that conclusion.

The distinction wasn't simply between using a machine and making everything by hand. In Zarya of the Dawn, the Office cancelled an existing registration and reissued narrower protection. The text and arrangement stayed protected. The Midjourney images did not.

The text and arrangement stayed protected, but the Midjourney images did not.

The text and arrangement stayed protected, but the Midjourney images did not. Dots: the open book, the text and arrangement, the Midjourney images.

Click a numbered dot to see what it stands for. Start with 1.

These are decisions about authorship, not instructions for pricing art. Allen v. Perlmutter remains undecided as of October 2026; it is Allen's own lawsuit against the Register of Copyrights, whose office refused to register his work. Still, the Office asks something Holker's arithmetic missed: which parts did the person control?

Ted Chiang puts choices at the center of art. In The New Yorker, he writes that "art is something that results from making a lot of choices."

I notice the difference when I let a tool make the first move and only edit afterward. I get less practice in the judgment I rely on. That judgment, built by making choices by hand, guides me before I start a piece or ask a tool to generate work.

I expect buyers who can check the work for themselves to pay for the choices made before the press, rather than the time spent producing it. I'd be wrong if they keep paying for hours once they can judge the result directly.

The hours that teach

The hours can still matter to the person doing them.

In January 2023, Nick Cave responded to a ChatGPT song written in his style. "Songs arise out of suffering," he wrote in The Red Hand Files. He meant the struggle of creation.

Cave wasn't refusing every possible encounter with AI. Later in the same letter, he admitted that one generated line spoke to him.

His concern reaches beyond whether a buyer likes the finished song. The maker goes through something while making it. The hours are also a school.

The maker goes through something while making it, and the hours are also a school.

The maker goes through something while making it, and the hours are also a school. Dots: the finished song, the buyer, the songwriter, the wall clock, the school desk.

Click a numbered dot to see what it stands for. Start with 1.

I recognize that in the practice I lose when I only edit. I expect that loss to matter even if the finished work satisfies a buyer. A record showing my judgment holding steady or improving would challenge that expectation.

Keeping that school doesn't require treating every hour as proof of value. I still have to judge what those hours produced. The author lets the tool draft first, decides which lines are good enough, and ships only those to the buyer.

Whistler won his libel suit. His published account records the award: "Damages one farthing." He was declared bankrupt in May 1879.

The two days were always the cheap part.

I keep these questions open in emails I send to people who join.