When We Became They

An accurate org chart can still leave people struggling to work together, for reasons a headcount will miss.

Two people write together on one shared sheet at a table under the words we decided. On the right a sheet slides out of a blue hatch window in a wall, with nobody behind it, to a woman waiting with open hands under the words they decided.

You notice it in the pronouns. People who used to say "we" start saying "they". Decisions still come from inside the same organization, but they sound as though someone else made them.

Nobody can quite say when that changed. As informal communication breaks down, "we" gives way to "they". People need an org chart to work out who does what.

The chart may be accurate. It still leaves a gap between knowing someone's role and knowing enough about them to work together.

That gap changes what a message has to carry. Without shared background, the message has to arrive complete. You can no longer rely on the other person to fill in what you left out.

You can feel this change before you can put a number on it. But a number would be reassuring: a point you could mark, a threshold you could avoid crossing.

The one people reach for is 150, attached to Robin Dunbar, a British anthropologist.

A company built to split

Bill and Vieve Gore started W. L. Gore & Associates on 1 January 1958. Their first workplace was the basement of their home in Newark, Delaware.

They put their life savings into the company. As it grew, Bill found that size changed how people worked together.

In 2000, Malcolm Gladwell reported Gore's verdict: "We found again and again that things get clumsy at a hundred and fifty". Gladwell did not identify the original interview.

Gary Hamel described the change more precisely: past a certain size, "we decided" became "they decided". Gladwell reported 150 employees per plant as the company goal. Hamel, allowing a few exceptions, gave 200 people per facility or manufacturing site as the limit.

Those are different numbers with different jobs. One was the size to aim for; the other was the outer limit.

In Dunbar's 2011 account, Gore responded by building another self-contained factory next door rather than enlarging the existing one. The company could grow without asking every local group to grow with it.

Gore died in 1986, before Dunbar published his research. He had reached his answer through experience.

Today, the company reports about 12,000 associates. Its directory lists ten Flagstaff facilities.

A mean, not a maximum

But Gore's experience does not establish a limit written into the brain.

The Hutterites offer another practical answer. Their own account says colonies begin establishing a daughter colony around 150 people, dividing families as evenly as possible.

Dunbar, drawing on accounts of Hutterite life, explains their reasoning: beyond that scale, peer pressure struggles to hold the community together. They prefer to divide rather than add formal enforcement.

The record is less tidy than the rule. Dunbar and Richard Sosis examined 97 recorded splits from 1880 to 1970. Colonies averaged 166.5 people when they split, with daughter communities averaging about 76 and 91.

Even Dunbar's original prediction was a mean, not a maximum. His extrapolation from primate brains produced 147.8, with a 95% range of roughly 100 to 231. He treated it as exploratory.

In 2021, Patrik Lindenfors, Andreas Wartel and Johan Lind challenged the calculation in Biology Letters. Their estimates ranged from 69 to 109 with one method, and 16 to 42 with another.

The corresponding 95% intervals stretched from 4 to 520 and 2 to 336. They concluded: "A cognitive limit on human group size cannot be derived in this manner."

That is a serious limit on what the calculation can tell you. It cannot support a precise ceiling.

Dunbar disputed their method. He said least-squares regression gave 71 on the same dataset, while his method gave 158.

Neither Gore nor the Hutterites needed that calculation to act.

Their decisions concerned what happened when people could no longer hold the group together in the old way.

What the headcount misses

Size still matters. Fifteen people have 105 possible pairs; 150 have 11,175. Those are possible connections, not a count of conversations or a measured cost.

Each extra chair adds a possible pair with everyone already there.

Each extra chair adds a possible pair with everyone already there. Dots, in order: the people already there, the extra chair, the new strings.

Click a numbered dot to see what it stands for. Start with 1.

Each extra chair adds a possible pair with everyone already there. More people can contribute more work while making it harder to keep track of one another.

Nor does knowing someone mean knowing everyone equally well. In his 2011 Guardian article, Dunbar described nested circles: five intimate friends, 15 good friends, 50 friends and 150 acquaintances.

In The Conversation in 2021, he said each layer is roughly three times the one inside it.

A team can therefore outgrow its way of working without crossing a universal boundary. Even at 15 good friends, a team can need an org chart. Beyond that team, the same choice faces a growing organization: add explicit roles and rules, or divide into groups that need less of them.

Add explicit roles and rules, or divide into groups that need less of them.

Add explicit roles and rules, or divide into groups that need less of them. Dots, in order: the growing group, the roles and rules, the split.

Click a numbered dot to see what it stands for. Start with 1.

For the Hutterites, keeping the larger group together would mean adding a police force. As Dunbar wrote of the Hutterites: "Rather than create a police force, they prefer to split the community."

Listen before the headcount looks decisive.

Are people saying "they" about decisions made inside the group? Does informal communication still work, and can people find one another without consulting the chart?

The organization can keep its name long after it loses its "we".

I keep a list of where "we" became "they", as I find it.