The Fact Was There

Why you can raise a warning twice and still get reassurance from a screen.

A nurse with braids and round glasses points at a rising bar chart on the wall beside a hospital bed, next to the words fact was there. Past a closed blue door in the wall between the rooms, a surgeon in a sweater stands with his back turned at an operating table under a lamp, next to the blue words somewhere else.

You told them twice, and the answer was a number on a screen.

Sorrel King's daughter Josie was 18 months old, healing from second-degree burns over 60 percent of her body. After nearly three weeks at Johns Hopkins Children's Center, home was days away.

But Josie was desperately thirsty, sucking her washcloth. By bedtime, her eyes were rolling back. Sorrel asked for a doctor. One nurse checked the monitor and said her vital signs were normal; a second nurse repeated the reassurance.

Each nurse answered from what the monitor could show. The chart held more: weight down nearly 20 percent, 14 soiled diapers in 24 hours. Nobody had put those facts together.

Each nurse answered from what the monitor could show.

Each nurse answered from what the monitor could show. Dots, in order: the monitor, the nurse, the chart.

Click a numbered dot to see what it stands for. Start with 1.

The next day, Paidas, the surgeon directing Josie's care, was in the operating room, so the pain team consulted other surgeons and agreed on a lower methadone dose. Sorrel still understood the order as no narcotics. A nurse arrived with a syringe.

"What are you doing?" Sorrel asked. The nurse explained that the order had changed.

Josie died February 22, 2001. Hopkins' first review identified dehydration and an unnecessary methadone dose. Its 2010 review added septic shock and said the narcotic was not to blame.

In her journal, published by the Baltimore Sun, Sorrel wrote: "Why did they not listen to me."

A hospital has charts, teams and a monitor, but a cockpit has two seats and one night.

On June 1, 2009, Air France 447 was flying from Rio to Paris with 228 people aboard. Ice crystals likely blocked its airspeed probes, and the autopilot disconnected. Four minutes and 23 seconds later, the aircraft hit the ocean.

The pilot flying pulled back on his stick. The other pilot could not easily see that input. The BEA, France's air-accident investigation agency, found that he was unaware of the climb.

The pilot flying pulled back on his stick.

The pilot flying pulled back on his stick. Dots, in order: the pilot flying, the stick, the other pilot.

Click a numbered dot to see what it stands for. Start with 1.

The captain returned to the cockpit. He would have needed to question the co-pilots about what had happened. The BEA found that urgency and the stress in the other pilot's voice blocked that approach.

Then the pilot flying said, in the BEA transcript: "But I've been at maxi nose-up for a while".

The captain spoke about two seconds later: "no no no don't climb".

Impact came 47 seconds after the pilot flying said it.

Speaking mattered. The BEA found that the co-pilots focused on their tasks at the expense of sharing essential information. The captain also needed access to what the pilot flying already knew.

Bring the decider closer, or give the fact a set path to the person who decides.

In 2010 Hopkins gave families a written list of activities they could do as part of care. A family member who sees signs of distress now has a defined part in care. Hopkins' own account says family members "often are the first to recognize signs of distress".

As in the telephone, each handoff compresses what the sender knew, and the next person works from the smaller picture. You said it, and it was written down; neither proves it reached someone who could act.

Each handoff compresses what the sender knew.

Each handoff compresses what the sender knew. Dots, in order: what the sender knew, the thinner stack, the smaller picture.

Click a numbered dot to see what it stands for. Start with 1.

The fact was there. The decision was somewhere else.

In each case I find, I write down where the fact lives and where its decision gets made.